Explosion risk within the built
environment or process facilities comes in various forms, but one of the least
discussed, and consequently poses an unknown risk, is the possibility of an
Aerosol Explosion, even below the liquid fuel’s flashpoint.
As per Gant, in a report
for HSE, the aerosol is defined as “colloidal dispersion of solid or liquid
particles mixed in gas”. One important aspect of aerosols is that we can
observe and see them in our everyday lives, such as spray deodorant, air
freshener, furniture polish, etc. Due to the fact that aerosol is basically a
mixture of liquid and gas, liquid hydrocarbon fuel is able to mix
with air to form hydrocarbon aerosol, and these hydrocarbon
aerosols pose not only fire risk but also explosion risk, subject to
dispersion conditions and containment of the system i.e. Lower Explosive Limit /
Lower Flammability Limit.
There are several ways aerosol
can be formed from liquid fuel below its flashpoints. As suggested by Gant
and HSE, which includes: high-pressure release, condensation, air stripping, and
agitation/splashing,
Due to the various ways aerosol
can be formed, it is clear to see why aerosol explosions pose a threat,
especially in chemical and process industries. In 2009, Santon conducted
an incident survey related to the ignition of mist/aerosol formed from
flammable liquids at temperatures below their flashpoints, and conclude that
the frequency of incidents is far greater than previously thought.
One possible explosion scenario
for Aerosol Explosion is a pinhole rupture of a pressurized, hydrocarbon
fuel line, which produces a leak and hydrocarbon aerosol release. The size of
the orifice or rupture dictates the dispersion of liquid fuel, and whether or
not Aerosol is produced. Dispersion is also an important factor as it
dictates the particle size which affects the overall Minimum Ignition
Energy. Therefore, a pinhole rupture of a pressurized, diesel fuel line
could produce Diesel Fuel Aerosol which poses an explosion hazard – even
below the liquid fuel’s flashpoint.
This is the main topic of my
Master’s Degree Dissertation during my studies at the University of Leeds –
Fire & Explosion Engineering, and the limitations of experiment results and
computer-based simulation of Aerosol Explosion drove me into pursuing a new
methodology of testing, using Hartmann Dust Explosion Apparatus – known
widely for dust explosion experiment only.
As it turns out, Hartmann
Dust Explosion Apparatus could be utilized as a basis of analysis for the Aerosol
Explosion phenomenon, albeit with some modification for the liquid fuel
dispersion method, and limitations in terms of repeatability. The experiment
was successful in terms of results, with Diesel Aerosol Explosion seen below
its flashpoint. The lean limit can be determined at 0.15 ∅
for the assumed burned diesel, with good repeatability especially at
stoichiometric, and at upper flammability range, the mixture kept exploding, suggesting
that there is no rich limit although further research is needed.
Other possible hydrocarbons aerosol production, as per Gant and HSE, also needs to be considered,
specifically for chemical / industrial facilities, process engineering, and its
environmental and surrounding factor. Condensation needs to be taken into
account, specifically for facilities with temperature differences, or situated
in climate within the condensation limit of the fuel. Air stripping and
agitation need to be taken into consideration for areas where spillage or
liquid pool occurs, and areas where pressurized air is utilized. In all
scenarios, it is also important to always check on the congestion level or
containment of liquid fuel – related to its Minimum Concentration and Lower
Flammability / Explosive Limit. Also worth noting that prevention is the best
solution, and keeping the availability of fuel and ignition sources is the basic
first step.
To read more about my research,
which focused mostly on experimental methodology using Hartmann Apparatus, you
can search for the paper titled: Mist Explosion using the Hartmann Dust
Explosion Equipment, published in XII ISHPMIE. 12th International Symposium on
Hazards, Prevention and Mitigation of Industrial Explosions – XII ISHPMIE,
12-17 Aug 2018, Kansas City, MO, USA. ISHPMIE.
Writer: Fahri Ali Imran - CEO Ignis Fire & Risk
0 Comments